Isle of Wight County (Va.) Criminal Records, 1774-1937

Access and use

Location of collection:
Library of Virginia
The Library of Virginia
800 East Broad Street
Richmond, VA 23219
Contact for questions and access:
POC: Archives Reference Services
Phone: (804) 692-3888

Summary

Creator:
Isle of Wight County (Va.) Circuit Court
Language:
English

Background

Scope and content:

Materials in the Library of Virginia’s collections contain historical terms, phrases, and images that are offensive to modern readers. These include demeaning and dehumanizing references to race, ethnicity, and nationality; enslaved or free status; physical and mental ability; religion; sex; and sexual orientation and gender identity.

Isle of Wight County (Va.) Criminal Records, 1774-1937 , consist of Free People in Want of Registration,1841; Commonwealth causes,1779-1867, pertaining to free and enslaved persons; and Commonwealth causes, 1774-1937, arranged chronologically.

Free People in Want of Registration, 184, consists of an affidavit noting William Bagwell being held as a "runaway" until proved he was a free man. Court ordered Bagwell to be hired out to pay for jail fees.

Commonwealth causes,1779-1867, involving free and enslaved Black and Multiracial individuals consists of criminal cases where the defendants themselves are either free or enslaved Black individuals. These cases also consist of white defendants who are charged with crimes involving matters of chattel slavery; violence against a free or enslaved Black persons; or other violations of laws involving the policing of Black communities.

Causes commonly found against free Black and enslaved people might include breaking and entering, stealing, assault, murder, arson, and aiding enslaved people to self-emancipate. Formerly enslaved men and women could also be tried for remaining in the commonwealth more than one year following emancipation. There are also cases against enslavers who permitted a gathering of enslaved people on their property.

Commonwealth causes, 1774-1937, pertaining to white and non-Black individuals as well as all post-1866 commonwealth causes are arranged chronologically but are otherwise unprocessed.

Biographical / historical:

Context for Records Type:

Free People in Want of Registration

Consists of lists of free Black and multiracial people confined to jail because they were without a free registration document or certificate proving their free status. In some localities, city sergeants or county sheriffs created reports for the court of individuals confined to jail. These documents serve as a certification record of who was in jail. Prisoners were required to pay the jail fees accrued during their time in jail. If they could not pay, they were hired out to cover the cost of their expenses. If this was the case, the document may indicate if they were hired out along with a totaling of expenses. For further research, search the minute books or court order books for the locality of interest.

Commonwealth Causes

Commonwealth causes are criminal court cases filed by the state government that consist primarily of warrants, summons, subpoenas, indictments, recognizances, and verdicts handed down by juries and other legal authorities in order to prosecute individuals who violated the penal code.

The commonwealth causes reveal an inconsistency in forms of conviction and punishment for white versus Black and multiracial individuals. Throughout the early nineteenth century, Virginia legislators revised the laws in ways that reduced the legal status of free Black and multiracial people to that of enslaved, thereby creating a legal system based on race. White Virginians and legislators feared insurrection and passed laws restricting the number of Black and multiracial people allowed to gather in groups. Enslavers could be fined for permitting their enslaved people to hire themselves out for work and enslaved people were jailed on these occasions. While public whipping originated as a form of punishment for all those convicted, in Virginia, it was retained for those who were Black, free or enslaved, and officially outlawed as a punishment for white criminals in 1848. Often, Black individuals served much longer penitentiary sentences while the cases of white men, who had committed the same or similar crimes, were dismissed.

Locality History: Isle of Wight County was named probably for the Isle of Wight off the south coast of England. It was first known as Warrosquyoake for an Indian tribe living in the area whose name means “swamp in a depression of land,” and was one of the original shires, or counties, first enumerated in 1634. The present name was given in 1637. Parts of Nansemond County were added in 1769 and 1772.

Lost Locality Note: Most pre–Revolutionary War–era loose records are missing. Volumes that record deeds, court orders, and wills exist. During the Civil War, the county clerk had Randall Boothe, a Black man he enslaved, transport the court records to Greensville and Brunswick counties for safekeeping. After the war ended, Boothe returned the records to Isle of Wight and served as courthouse caretaker.

Acquisition information:
These records came to the Library of Virginia in a transfer of court papers from Isle of Wight County in an undated accession.
Arrangement:

This collection is arranged

  • Series I: Free People in Want of Registration, 1841
  • Series II: commonwealth causes,1779-1867, pertaining to free and enslaved persons, and are arranged chronologically.
  • Series III: Commonwealth causes, 1774-1937, arranged chronologically.

Physical location:
Library of Virginia
Physical description:
11.25 cu. ft. (15 boxes); digital images