- Parrish, Edward Evans, 1791-18741
- Parsons, Job W.3
- Patterson, James Howard, 1867-19491
- Pemberton, William1
- Perrigo, George W.1
- Phillips, Marcia Louise Sumner1
- Plummer, Patrick1
- Porter, George McCandless (1835-1864)1
- Preston, David R.1
- Price's Tavern1
- Price, William, 1803-18811
- Protzman, William I.1