- 50th Anniversary of African American Students in Residence Collection, 2017/20184
- Adam Barger Campaign files, 20192
- Alejandro Rodríguez Fornés (Alucho) collection, 2014/20197
- Alexandra Wingate collection, 2016/20191
- Alexis Brender A. Brendis certificate, 20192
- Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority, Inc. (Nu Chi Chapter) Collection, 1981/20201
- Auxiliary Services records, 1962/20192
- Baseball records, 1908/20241
- Bishop James Madison Society records, 1996/20212
- Board of Visitors records, 1757/202310
- Bobak Kasrai collection of Alpha Phi Alpha Fraternity, Inc. (Kappa Pi Chapter) materials, 2000/20201
- Booton-Modesitt Family Papers, 1809/1880, bulk 1820/18501
- Capital Club of Williamsburg Records, 1960/2015, bulk 1970/20002
- Cartelistas Cubanos por el Futuro collection, 2019/202027
- Chamber Music Society of Williamsburg (CMSW) papers, 1987/202421