- Alumni Association Records, 1833/2014, bulk 1950/20051
- Austin-Twyman Papers, 1765/193930
- Blow Family Papers, 1613/1960, bulk 1770/18756
- Borland Family Papers, 1771/19401
- Brown, Coalter, Tucker Papers (I), 1790/19293
- Brown, Coalter, Tucker Papers (II), 1791/19208
- Bruton Parish Church (Williamsburg, Va.) records, 1662/2010, bulk 1900/20001
- Coleman-Kimbrough papers, 1870/19921
- Cook-Luttrell Papers, 1848/18905
- Edward "Teddy" Bolton Tucker Papers, 1760/2007, bulk 1800/19002
- Gloucester Circuit of the Methodist Church Records, 1825/19103
- Grigsby-Galt Papers, 1736/1982, bulk 1840/19302
- Hamilton Family Papers, 1892/2003, bulk 1930/20031
- Harrison Holt Riddleberger Papers, 1872/19023
- Hart collection, 1762/19391