- Blackley Family papers, 1830/20201
- Charles T. Smith photographs, 1880/2007, bulk 1990/19991
- Christopher Bram Papers, 1968/2014, bulk 1975/20001
- Christopher Wren Singers Records, 1989/2012, bulk 1993/20031
- Douglas Gordon's The vanity of allegory, 20051
- Earl and Jewell Ratliff Collection, 1860/2013, bulk 1920/19901
- Ephemera Collection, 1800/20141
- Flippo Gallery, 1979/20236
- Henkel Family Papers, 1801/20081
- Phil Teigen North American churches postcard collection, 1904/20101
- Racial and Ethnic Ephemera Collection, 1778/20051
- Williamsburg (Va.) Area Ephemera Collection, 1858/20151
- Williamsburg Reunion Collection, 1968/20101