- Alumni Association Photograph Collection, 1960/2010, bulk 1970/19901
- Alumni Band Organization Records, 1986/2012, bulk 1986/20001
- Ann Buckles Papers, 1950/20081
- Anne and Alan Morledge Collection, 1946/2005, bulk 1969/19881
- Armand J. Galfo Papers, 1940/2008, bulk 1958/19951
- Art Song of Williamsburg Records, 2000/20071
- Association for the Preservation of Virginia Antiquities, Yorktown Branch Records, 1921/2013, bulk 1975/20051
- Bruton Parish Church (Williamsburg, Va.) records, 1662/2010, bulk 1900/20001
- C. James Gleason Photography Collection, 1987/20081
- Capital Club of Williamsburg Records, 1960/2015, bulk 1970/20001
- Carl A. "Pappy" Fehr papers, 1907/2012, bulk 1945/19741
- Charles Edward Gary, Jr. Papers, 1870/2000, bulk 1940/19801
- Charles and William Person Papers, 1900/2011, bulk 1920/19501
- Christopher Bram Papers, 1968/2014, bulk 1975/20001
- Circle K International Records, 1958/2009, bulk 1958/19641