- Janet C. Kimbrough Williamsburg Area History Collection, 1873/19941
- Jay G. Rainey Papers, 1970/1996, bulk 1970/19771
- Jay W. Johns Jr. Collection of James Monroe Papers, 1780/18341
- Jennings C. Wise papers, 1910/19601
- Joanne V. Gabbin Papers, 1930/2017, bulk 1960/20171
- John Frederick Pierson Papers, 1864/19251
- John Lesslie Hall, Jr. Papers, 1893/19731
- John Tyler, Jr. Papers, 1800/19281
- Jubal A. Early Papers, 1863/18901
- Julia W. Oxrieder Papers, 1877/19981
- Kenneth W. Newman Records, 1971/20041
- Letters and pamphlets regarding Fenwick, Mason, & Company legal cases and appeals1
- Lexington Presbyterian Church collection, 1824/1927, bulk 1877/19271
- Lynne Olver Collection, 20151
- Maakestad Collection, 1972/19841