- Baseball records, 1908/20241
- Department of Athletics records, 1915/20131
- George McFadden Ultimate Frisbee Team jersey and photographs, 1988/19901
- Herbert W. Hausmann papers, 1959/19931
- Men's Basketball records, 1925/20241
- Men's and Women's Gymnastics records, 1974/20151
- Men's and Women's Soccer Records, 1965/20221
- Men's and Women's Tennis records, 1947/20241
- Track and Field/Cross Country records, 1986/20241
- William & Mary Ultimate Frisbee collection, 1982/20181
- William & Mary Women's Club Soccer Gold Team records, 2000/20061
- William & Mary Women's Ultimate Frisbee records, 1990/20201
- William Kenneth Close collection, 19201
- Women's Basketball records, 1939/20241