- Beverly Simonton Kelly Letters, 1949/19981
- Bishop James Madison Society records, 1996/20211
- David McKinney Papers, 1977/20131
- Delta Omicron (Delta Tau Chapter) records, 1950/20181
- Elizabeth Edwards Wingate Photograph Album, 1983/20141
- Football records, 1923/20201
- Kappa Kappa Gamma (Gamma Kappa Chapter) Records, 1923/20141
- Men's and Women's Soccer Records, 1965/20221
- Meridian Coffeehouse Records, 1996-[ongoing], 19961
- Psi Upsilon Fliers and Photographs, 1982/20041
- The Flat Hat records, 1911/20191
- Theta Delta Chi (Epsilon Charge) Records, 1853/20071
- William & Mary Hip Hop collection, 1985/2019, bulk 2012/20141
- William & Mary Women's Ultimate Frisbee records, 1990/20201