- Africana Studies Program records, 1996/20141
- Alpha Chi Omega (Beta Delta chapter) Sorority records, 1990/20071
- Alpha Phi Alpha Kappa Pi chapter records, 1972/20111
- Alumni Band Organization Records, 1986/2012, bulk 1986/20001
- Bishop James Madison Society records, 1996/20211
- Board of Visitors records, 1757/20231
- C. James Gleason Photography Collection, 1987/20081
- Canterbury Association Records, 1954/2013, bulk 1980/20001
- Carl A. "Pappy" Fehr papers, 1907/2012, bulk 1945/19741
- Chi Omega (Omicron Beta Chapter) Records, 1921/20121
- Christmas Activities Collection, 1942/20021
- Christopher Wren Singers Records, 1989/2012, bulk 1993/20031
- Circle K International Records, 1958/2009, bulk 1958/19641
- Class Histories and Activities collection, 1905/20141
- College of William and Mary Directory Collection, 1827/20131