- Amos Koontz Papers I, 1809/1965, bulk 1936/19651
- Anatole and Vladimir Kalichevsky Papers, 1871/19551
- Augustine Smith Papers, 1787/17931
- Blizzard Family Papers, 1929/1949, bulk 1942/19451
- Carter Lowance Papers, 1860/1993, bulk 1942/19881
- Caskie Stinnett Papers, 1919/1998, bulk 1950/19931
- Charles Edward Gary, Jr. Papers, 1870/2000, bulk 1940/19801
- Christopher Bram Papers, 1968/2014, bulk 1975/20001
- Colvin Papers, 1734/18391
- Dale Family Papers, 1915/19171
- Dora and Cara Armistead Papers, 1880/19501
- Edward Ashby Armstrong Papers, 18951
- Edward Belvin Collection of Williamsburg and James City County materials, 1874/19871
- Evelyn M. Hailey Papers, 1970/1990, bulk 1974/19861
- F.H.C. Society Collection, 1911/20121