- Carter Lowance Papers, 1860/1993, bulk 1942/19881
- Caskie Stinnett Papers, 1919/1998, bulk 1950/19931
- Charles Edward Gary, Jr. Papers, 1870/2000, bulk 1940/19801
- Edward Belvin Collection of Williamsburg and James City County materials, 1874/19871
- F.H.C. Society Collection, 1911/20121
- Glenna G. Shiflett Papers, 1961/19931
- Grigsby-Galt Papers, 1736/1982, bulk 1840/19301
- Hall Family Papers, 1810/20071
- J. Wilfred Lambert Papers, 1920/19741
- Jamestown Corporation Records, 1946/19791
- John Garland Pollard Papers, 1683/1968, bulk 1856/19371
- Lawrence I'Anson Papers, 1938/19831
- Lee Family Papers, 1858/1976, bulk 1900/19501
- Mortar Board Records, 1929/20141
- Office of Admission records, 1861/20211