- Board of Visitors records, 1757/20231
- Carter Lowance Papers, 1860/1993, bulk 1942/19881
- David A. Bucher Papers, 1769/19121
- Gloucester Circuit of the Methodist Church Records, 1825/19101
- John Garland Pollard Papers, 1683/1968, bulk 1856/19371
- John Lesslie Hall, Jr. Papers, 1893/19731
- Lassiter Papers, 1861/19281
- Myers-Burrage-Graham Papers (I) Group B, 1888/19421
- Spew Marrow Agricultural Club Papers, 1876/19341
- Toano High School Library Association Record Book, 1908/19341
- United Daughters of the Confederacy Williamsburg (Va.) records, 1890/19981
- Violet McDougall Pollard papers, 1907/1976, bulk 1933/19681
- William Booth Taliaferro Papers, 1811/19541